The Democratic makeover of the state Legislature includes several changes to the committee structure intended to highlight the importance of water and climate policy to the new liberal majority.
In the House, the Natural Resources, Energy and Water Committee is being renamed the Water, Environment and Energy Committee under the leadership of incoming chair Chris Mathis, a Tucson Democrat and water wonk.
“The new committee name … reflects a shift from my predecessor’s focus on shielding certain actors from oversight and accountability to a focus on preserving shared resources for all Arizonans,” Mathis told us recently.
And in a bigger change, Senate leadership is breaking what was the Senate Natural Resources, Water and Energy Committee into two: a standalone Water Committee and a Climate, Energy and Natural Resources Committee.
At the helm of the Water Committee will be new Senate President Priya Sundareshan, an environmental attorney by trade and the leading voice on water in the Democratic caucus.
The Water Committee is “new, and the president as chair is a signal of water’s importance to the state,” Sundareshan said in a text.
On one level, this is just semantics. Chamber leaders have significant latitude in where and whether bills are heard, regardless of what committees are called.
But these rebrands reflect a philosophical shift, especially in separating water from natural resources, suggesting more of a focus on water for its own sake, not only as something to be used or consumed.
“On water, the committee has for years been used to advance an alternate reality premised on the falsehood that not only does our state have an abundance of water at our disposal, but that the only real problem from a policy perspective is that the rules surrounding the use of that water are too strict,” Mathis said. “In fact, the reality we’re facing is quite the opposite, and the resulting challenges are quite real. There are plenty of ways to address this situation, and those will be reflected in the bills we hear and pass as well as the discussions we have.”
Sundareshan’s role on the Water Committee is especially notable. We can’t remember the last time that the leader of a chamber also headed a policy committee. And that’s not without reason.
Being the House speaker or Senate president is time-consuming, and so is chairing a high-traffic committee. It’s much more common to see legislative leadership on the Rules Committee or in vice chairmanships, as will be the case on the House side next year. We’ll have to see how Sundareshan balances these responsibilities.
Policy committee assignments are important.
As we’ve written on numerous occasions, past water legislation — particularly rural groundwater regulations — repeatedly stalled before Gail Griffin, a longtime Republican lawmaker and Arizona Farm Bureau ally who has chaired the water and natural resource committees in both chambers.
We can now expect many of those bills, starting with a rural groundwater package, to progress through the Legislature.
We don’t know exactly what form they’ll take, though Sundareshan gave us some idea in a recent interview.
And we don’t know how parsimonious Democrats will be with Republican bills.
Is revenge a dish best served wet (or dry, as it were)?

This is as good a time as any to offer a brief primer on the groundwater debate. To the books we go.
Groundwater Management Act
Arizona, a conservation pioneer?
Heading into 1980, fast-growing Arizona was mining its underground water supplies to critical levels. The Central Arizona Project, a canal to bring Colorado River water to the state’s population centers — thus relieving pressure on the aquifers — had been approved by Congress more than a decade earlier, but it still hadn’t been financed. Thanks to some shrewd politicking from Arizona lawmakers and others, the federal government was willing to foot the bill for most of the great concrete snake, but not without conditions: The state had to seriously curtail groundwater pumping.
The result was the Groundwater Management Act of 1980, passed under the governorship of semi-legendary water nerd Bruce Babbitt, still a fixture at Colorado River events and conferences more than four decades later.
At the time, it was a regulatory structure without peer in the nation. It created four “Active Management Areas” in the Prescott, Phoenix, Tucson and Pinal County regions where groundwater pumping was tightly regulated.
It also created “Irrigation Non-expansion Areas” in Joseph City and Douglas (and soon Harquahala) where there are restrictions on new irrigated agricultural acreage.

A map of Arizona’s AMAs and INAs
And it stood up the state’s Assured Water Supply rules, which, very broadly, require homebuilders and developers in AMAs to demonstrate a 100-year water supply that is “physically, legally, and continuously available.” How this availability requirement is understood, measured and enforced is a hot political issue, but one we’ll avoid delving into for now.
Active Management Areas
Whether from the voters or via executive action (the latter not without controversy), there are now eight AMAs: Phoenix, Tucson, Pinal, Prescott, Santa Cruz, Douglas, Willcox and Ranegras Plain.
The AMAs have different goals and regulations depending on their economies and hydrologic situations. In Phoenix, Tucson, Santa Cruz and Prescott, the goal is “Safe Yield,” meaning the rate of groundwater recharge is equal to or greater to the rate of extraction.
But none of the AMAs reached that goal in a consistent manner by the supposed deadline of 2025, nor was there much expectation that they would, as Arizona water scholars Sarah Porter and Kathleen Ferris noted in a 2021 paper. There are simply too many ways for groundwater to still be pumped, and too few restrictions on non-residential (e.g., agricultural and industrial) users.
This isn’t the only problem with the Groundwater Management Act and its AMAs. Hydrologic basins are not tidy buckets suited to legal divisions. Some critics have noted that the basin-wide safe yield requirement obscures the fact that some parts of an AMA are in better shape than others. Pumping outside of AMAs can also cause aquifer depletion within them.
Perhaps the biggest issue is, simply, that outside of AMAs, there is essentially no regulation on groundwater pumping.
This is an immediate, potentially existential problem for many rural Arizona communities, especially for those without the political and economic power of large farms, mines and developments.
In a legislative session that’s already shaping up to be water-heavy, this is why Democrats are so intent on introducing groundwater reform bills. Patching the holes in groundwater management proved essentially impossible in the era of divided government.
Without institutional barriers like GOP committee chairs, the Dems are hoping for better luck this time around.
But there are still plenty of powerful interests and thorny legal questions at play in groundwater management. So we will keep our expectations in check, for now.

Setting the tone: One of the looming questions for the upcoming legislative session is whether the new Democratic majority will seek revenge on their Republican colleagues. Tucson-area Democratic Sen.-elect Alma Hernandez says she wants the Democrats to treat Republican lawmakers with respect when the Legislature reconvenes in January, the Arizona Mirror’s Caitlin Sievers reports. Hernandez also included lobbyists in her call for civility, saying “lobbyists are human too.”
“We’re basically not going to treat people like shit,” Hernandez said.
Mayes vs. Musk: Attorney General Kris Mayes is urging Cochise County officials to pump the brakes on the massive proposed SpaceX data center. The county’s planning and zoning commission is scheduled to vote on a special use permit for the data center on December 9, but Mayes said the commissioners should delay the vote until they’ve fully considered the “unprecedented scale” of the data center, which would use 6 gigawatts of electricity, or roughly one-fifth of the state’s power-generating capacity.
Public pressure: Amid widening public opposition to school closures, Tucson Unified School District Governing Boardmembers Sadie Shaw and Jennifer Eckstrom say they’ll vote against the closure plan on December 8, Noor Haghighi reports for Arizona Public Media. Shaw and Eckstrom would need a third vote to kill the closure plan. Recently elected Boardmember Pilar Acosta Ruiz won’t be seated until after the vote, but she might challenge the closure plan alongside Shaw and Eckstrom, KOLD’s Valerie Cavazos reports.
“If it is voted on on December 8 and there’s pieces of it that I don’t agree with, then I will most likely ask to have some of that brought back under the new board,” Acosta Ruiz said.
Trying again: Tohono O’odham Nation officials filed a complaint asking a federal judge to block contractors from trespassing on tribal lands to build a wall along the Arizona-Mexico border, Paul Ingram reports for the Tucson Sentinel. The tribe sued the federal government this summer to protect saguaros that would be destroyed, but a federal judge denied its request.
Last hurdle cleared: The immigration detention center in Marana is inching toward opening in the next few months, now that town officials signed off on a business license, Yana Kunichoff reports for the Arizona Luminaria. While the paperwork was tidied up, executives at Management and Training Corporation, the company that’s going to run the detention center in a former state prison, dodged accusations that a clerk at the prison commissary had an illicit sexual relationship with an inmate in 2022, per Hannah Cree at the Arizona Daily Star.

Finally, the election-denying train appears to be running out of steam.
Four years after Cochise County Supervisor Tom Crosby (and former Supervisor Peggy Judd) spewed nonsense claims about the 2022 elections, he joined the other supervisors in certifying the results of the November 3 elections.
When it came time to speak publicly about the election results this week, all he had to say was:
“I just wanted to thank Ms. Avant (the county elections director Melissa Avant), county staff, and all the citizen participants,” Crosby said.
He might have more to say to a judge if he goes to trial for his pending felony charges related to interfering with the 2022 election results.
Until then, we’re just glad this clown show is winding down.




