By now, you’ve probably read a million stories about “what the Democrats are going to do when they take over the Legislature.”
We hate to add to the pile, but Arizona’s political world just got turned on its head, and there’s a lot to figure out.
Right now, Southern Arizona’s education world is abuzz with the possibilities of a political party being in charge that vocally supports public schools.
Still, education leaders are aware of the ironclad political and legal limits placed on public education that a single blue wave can’t undo.
We picked the brains of three Pima County education leaders to find out what they hope the new class of Arizona legislators prioritizes.
Dustin Williams
Pima County School Superintendent, first elected in 2016. Before that, he was a classroom teacher and the assistant director of the Ha:san Preparatory & Leadership School, a Native American charter school. A few years after he was elected, he established the Pima County Cycle Breakers, which helps justice-involved adolescents and young adults obtain their high school diploma, GED or certification, plus wraparound supports. A few days after we spoke with him, Democratic Superintendent of Public Instruction-elect Teresa Leyba Ruiz announced Williams would be part of her transition team.
Williams had no shortage of ideas about what he thinks should be high on the new Democratic majority’s to-do list.
“Schools have been bombarded, playing defense,” he said.
Among the state policies Williams says need to be revisited are the expired school funding stream known as Prop 123, the state’s letter-grade system and schools’ aggregate expenditure limit.
This summer, the Arizona Auditor General’s Office issued a report showing flaws in the state’s letter-grade accountability system. Changes to the conglomeration of data — which some say Arizonans have put far too much stock in — are expected to be finalized by the end of this year.
The aggregate expenditure limit puts a limit on public school spending. Go over that cap, and schools are penalized with state budget cuts. Big cuts. The formula is an old, hot mess that was implemented in the 1980s and comes back to haunt public schools on a regular basis.
And Prop 123 was a $300 million annual funding stream that schools got from the state land trust fund as a settlement for the Legislature illegally skipping voter-mandated inflation funding during the Great Recession. It expired in 2025, and lawmakers have been paying that extra $300 million out of the state general fund ever since.
Reforming, repealing and renewing these policies are big asks that involve rethinking some policies that have been around a long, long time.
Reconsidering them “needs to be done in a really intelligent manner, and it needs to be coming from the local level up,” Williams said.
If school districts can even get to the mic, that is.
Williams said school districts have struggled to be heard at the Capitol, while also lacking the bandwidth to explain to families what orders coming from on high mean to them.
Beyond the Legislature, voters elected a Democrat, Leyba Ruiz, to be the next superintendent of public instruction and oversee Arizona’s public schools.
“We were constantly fighting so many pieces of legislation that were harmful to the success of students,” he said. “The last administration was focused so heavily on vouchers and … the penalization of teachers and culture wars.”
But with Democrats in the Governor’s Office, Legislature and superintendent of public instruction role, Williams said he recently told a group of teachers:
“You’re going to get a chance now to focus on your craft and your kids, not acronyms and scrubbing words.”
John Carruth
Superintendent, Vail Unified School District. Carruth has been at VUSD in various capacities since 1995. As superintendent, he played a pivotal role in the district adopting a year-round school model. Carruth paused his work with VUSD to serve as chief of staff on then-incoming Superintendent of Public Instruction Kathy Hoffman’s transition team. This week, Leyba Ruiz’s team announced that Carruth will be on her transition task force.
Carruth offered a few “straightforward fixes” for the House and Senate to take on.
One fix Carruth suggested: settling Arizona’s capital funding lawsuit.
A Maricopa County Superior Court judge dropped the gavel in 2026, ruling the state’s funding system unconstitutional. A group of school districts (none in Pima County) and a handful of education organizations filed the lawsuit, arguing the state violated its own constitution regarding public school funding uniformity.
The court gave Arizona’s Legislature and governor eight months from its March ruling to make things right. (That’s this month, for those of you counting fingers.)
Republican lawmakers appealed the ruling, defending the existing system. The appeal is in limbo, though, as the incoming Legislature’s newly blue majorities will likely make the capital funds fight look much different.
And, of course, school vouchers, or Empowerment Scholarship Accounts, came up during our chat with Carruth.
There are a significant number of “great parents” enrolling students in private and charter schools with ESA assistance, he noted. And that’s fine, Carruth said. What he wants is accountability for those institutions to even the playing field with public schools.
“This doesn’t become an issue about (families). They’re trying to do what’s best for their kids.”
Carruth said schools receiving public dollars should adhere to the same standards applied to public schools — including uniform testing requirements. (Jessica went more in depth about the patchwork of current testing requirements when she spoke to KJZZ in May.)
Carruth also brought up something that can’t be solved in one fell swoop: how often lawmakers design and enact policies targeting education anomalies, which he says causes a lot of frustration.
One example is HB2610 — sponsored by outgoing Republican Rep. Matt Gress — which was based on Tolleson Union High School District and Isaac Elementary School District’s lease-leaseback agreement.
Sure, the legislation did have some merit … except the only other lease-leaseback arrangements in existence are exercised by privately owned charter schools. The bill, had Gov. Katie Hobbs not vetoed it, wouldn’t have applied to charter schools.
Still, introducing targeted legislation isn’t reserved for Republicans, Carruth pointed out. Democrats have done the same thing.
Natalie Luna Rose
Governing Board member, Tucson Unified School District. Luna Rose was first elected to the board smack dab in the middle of the COVID-19 pandemic. Oof. When ICE came knocking on schools’ doors, Luna Rose was adamant about having solid districtwide policies in place to protect students and district employees. More recently, Luna Rose and her fellow board members have been facing tough decisions and balancing intense emotions surrounding TUSD school consolidations.
As TUSD looks to shutter schools, Luna Rose argued stingy state funding and declining enrollment are forcing the district’s hand.
“I’ve been serving on a school board for a district that has been continuously shortchanged for years now,” she said.
When state budgets came up for redesign, Luna Rose said TUSD kept clinging to hopes they’d “see a little bit of money.”
Best-case scenario, things remained the same. Worst case, the district received even less, she said.
Before the recently proposed consolidations — and before Prop 123 was abandoned — the district asked local taxpayers for targeted help, in the form of a bond and an override.
“The community said yes, and I will always thank the Tucson voters for that — but it still is not enough. I’m hoping with this new Legislature that we’ll finally see some extra funding come in, so we’re not having to do school closures in another five to 10 years, or another override, or another bond.”
Luna Rose echoed Williams’ wish for the state’s funding formula to be revisited.
Maybe dreams truly do come true, and someday public schools become fully funded … but in the meantime, there are a handful of other things on Luna Rose’s wish list, including that lawmakers will “stop focusing on DEI and culture war nonsense.”
Beyond education, Luna Rose said Tucson itself deserves more of the state’s respect.
“Tucson’s always been the redheaded stepchild. We’re a vibrant city, and we have good working families here. Tucson can be a powerhouse — if you let it,” she said. Instead, “the state and the Legislature have kind of ignored Tucson,” except for occasionally “giving Tucson just enough to shut us up.”

Not so fast: A federal judge blocked a Trump administration effort to limit how long international students can stay in the country, which prompted sighs of relief from Tucson’s higher education community, Prerana Sannappanavar reports for the Star. The Trump administration rampaged through higher education last year, and international students were one of the top targets.
“First and foremost, it provides a measure of protection for international students ... from one of the arbitrary, unjustified and xenophobic practices of DHS under the Trump administration,” UA Faculty Chair Leila Hudson wrote to the Star.
TEP rates on the rise: The Arizona Corporation Commission backed a 10% rate increase for Tucson Electric Power, Tucson Sentinel’s Blake Morlock reports. TEP’s 458,000 rate payers will pay roughly an additional $13 a month under the new plan, but approval came with a demand that TEP also do a cost study on large scale data centers like Project Blue. Tucson-based Corporation Commissioner Lea Marquez Peterson was the lone vote against the increase.
Save our school: A few dozen parents and their kids attending TUSD’s Marguerite L. Collier Elementary School protested the planned closure of the school on Tuesday morning, saying they have a three-year plan to convert the K-6 school into a K-8 school, with a focus on environmental learning. More than 1,000 people have signed a petition to keep the school in northeast Tucson open as TUSD looks to consolidate schools to cut costs, parents told us.

Parents and students protest outside of Marguerite L. Collier Elementary School on Tuesday. (Photo by Joe.)
Prop 207 clapback: While Arizona Democrats debate whether to impose a moratorium on data centers next year, legal experts caution that the voter-approved Prop 207 could put local governments on the hook for millions of dollars if they try to block data centers at the local level, the Republic’s Alaina Mencinger and Laura Gersony report. The law, which passed on the 2006 ballot, requires property owners to be compensated if land-use regulations diminish their property value. A Goldwater Institute lawyer called Pima County’s recent temporary moratorium on data centers “draconian,” but, as we wrote a few weeks ago, the Pima County moratorium exempts the only two known data centers in front of the supervisors right now.
Not a new problem: Following two separate stabbings, including one that killed a man, at the Ronstadt Transit Center last weekend, the Star’s Tim Steller dug into the newspaper’s archives to look at the history of the downtown transportation hub. Twenty-two years ago, the paper was writing about crime at Ronstadt Center, although he noted those crimes were primarily “trespassing, theft, disorderly conduct.” The columnist also interviewed a dozen people riding the bus on Monday afternoon, most of whom said they felt perfectly safe on public transportation.

When the Pima County Fair comes to town in April 2027, there won’t be any sea lions or tigers. Probably no bears, either.
Oh my.
Local activists have been putting pressure on the county to stop bringing exotic animals to the annual fair, and to their credit, officials are listening.
County Administrator Jan Lesher made it official with a memo earlier this week, noting that sea lions and tigers specifically won’t be part of the fair.
Now the most dangerous part of the fair will be the food. We wish the activists luck getting a deep-fried Oreo released back into the wild.


